Show More

Ask an Expert

Is it worth having fully comp on an old car?

Fully comprehensive car insurance covers you for any damage to yours or another's vehicle should you get into an accident. If you’ve got an old car, you might wonder whether this kind of policy is worth having.

After all, it provides better coverage than third-party, so it must be more expensive. But strangely enough, this isn’t always the case.

Despite being slightly counter-intuitive, fully comprehensive car insurance can be cheaper than third-party only. This is because there are proportionately more claims by those with third-party coverage. So, this means that many providers will actually charge more, as there is a statistically higher chance of an accident.

It’s important to note that this isn’t always going to be the case. However, it’s worth checking as if you can get more for less, then why wouldn’t you?

If you are in a situation where a third-party is cheaper, then, depending on the value of the car, third-party might be worth considering. 

When a provider is assessing how much your policy will be, they will look at a few different factors. One of the most influential will be how much your car is worth. If its value is lower, then a potential claim would be a lot less. Therefore, your premiums could be very affordable.

As you can see, whether you should have fully comp on an old car depends on a few factors. We would always recommend checking out how much fully comp costs before taking out a third-party policy, as most of the time, you will be able to get a deal that is at least comparable in price.

*51% of consumers could save £535.17 on their Car Insurance. The saving was calculated by comparing the cheapest price found with the average of the next four cheapest prices quoted by insurance providers on Seopa Ltd’s insurance comparison website. This is based on representative cost savings from May 2026 data. The savings you could achieve are dependent on your individual circumstances and how you selected your current insurance supplier.

Related guides

Dash Cams and Car Insurance

Dash cam insurance is becoming more and more popular. But what is it, and why are people opting for it?Well, if you’ve been involved in a driving dispute and had to make an insurance claim, then you’ll be familiar with the 'your word against theirs' grey area. In this guide, we’ll take you through dash cams and how they can affect your car insurance.

Car and Vehicle Tax Explained - Money Expert

If you want to drive a vehicle on public roads you must register it and pay a car ‘tax’. This tax varies depending on how old your car is, its worth, and crucially how much carbon dioxide (CO2) it emits. This guide will take you through the key points of car tax, how much you might have to pay, and what happens when you buy or sell a car.

A Guide To The Cheapest Job Titles For Car Insurance

Did you know you could get cheaper car insurance by wording your job title slightly differently? Or that the driving behaviour of other people in your profession can affect your own car insurance quote?Let's take a look at how your job title affects your car insurance, and how you can make your car insurance cheaper even if you're in a high-risk profession.